Comment by πŸš€ stack

Re: "What is analog computing? The basic idea is there is some…"

In: u/Analog_Guy

I've never heard of 'analog computing' used as in modeling some behavior. Have you really?

πŸš€ stack

2025-12-29 Β· 4 months ago

1 Later Comment

πŸš€ Analog_Guy [OP] Β· Dec 29 at 21:32:

Professor Ulmann gives a similar explanation in his book, "Analog Computing", ISBN 978-3110787610. I do not have the book on hand, right now, or I would try to give a better reference. I believe he also pointed out that analog computing does not mean "non-discrete" as even electronic analog computers are computationally discrete down at the electron level.

The core idea is that there is a physical analogue between the computation and the computational device. "Modeling some behavior" is not exactly the same thing as that, although modeling behavior was a very common use of electronic analog computers. Slide rules are analog computing devices, but they do not really model or simulate any system.

Original Post

πŸš€ Analog_Guy

What is analog computing? The basic idea is there is some physical analog between the computing device and the computing to be performed. A slide rule is a non-electronic computing device in which the analog is physical distances on logarithmic scales. A traditional electronic analog computer represents values as varying voltages which are feed through computing elements like integrators and multipliers.

πŸ’¬ 17 comments Β· 2025-12-24 Β· 4 months ago